eating disorder posts, Uncategorized

Veganism is the same as an eating disorder? Veganism is just hiding an eating disorder?

I have to start off by being fully honest and saying that before i went vegan i did think that veganism was restrictive and that most people who were vegan had an eating disorder.

I wondered why would someone not want to eat Ben and Jerrys or Marabou chocolate or eat egg yolks if it wasnt because those foods were fear foods and the person had some form of an eating disorder. Now of course i know better and know WHY a person wouldn’t eat those foods and it has nothing to do with calories or fears, but because of ethical beliefs.

IMG_20170620_131334_604 (2)

I must admit, i am embarassed that i thought this and it was very close minded of me however i can’t deny that there are MANY people who have eating disorders and eat a plant based diet or live a fully vegan lifestyle.

Some in recovery from an eating disorder say that changing to a vegan lifestyle and diet helped them recover, which is amazing! However others i believe go vegan just so that they have a *valid* reason to not eat certain foods and to continue restricting and only eating safe foods. There have been some from social media who i follow who over the years have come out and said that they were vegan only because of their eating disorder and that their realtionship with food wasn’t balanced or healthy. This of course makes it seem as if everyone who goes vegan also has an eating disorder. But this is not the case.

Veganism is NOT synonym for an eating disorder and it is not restrictive. However if your mindset is unhealthy and your relationship with food is restrictive, then it doesnt matter what type of diet you follow, it will still be restrictive.

If you have a healthy relationship with food and can eat enough and can eat balanced then a plant based diet isn’t restrictive at all because there are so many options. There is vegan junk food and vegan processed food, but also you can make plenty of balanced and nutrient dense meals which will help you reach the right vitamin and mineral amount you need daily.

My advice is that if someone is recovering from an eating disorder, you shouldn’t eat plant based. There are many reasons for this and one of the reasons is that when recovering from an eating disorder you should have no restrictions on what you allow yourself to eat, but also that the body has been through alot and that the uptake of vitamins and minerals might not be as good, leading to defieciency, compared to someone who has a healthy and functioning digestive system. Not to mention, as already written above, if a person has an unhealthy realtionship with food and has certain fear foods then a plant based diet might just keep the person restricted and never fully recover as they don’t face their fear foods. With that being said, i dont mean that a person should eat meat and dairy 6 times a day to recover, but to atleast be open to all foods and maybe that means eating a ben and jerrys every second week because that is what the person really wants and needs and eats plant based 98% of the time otherwise. My recommendation if you want to be vegan and are recovering from an eating disorder is to instead focus on the other things you can do to help the animals and the planet (a post about this coming up!), and eat plant based meals throughout the week and in time go fully vegan if you can stay healthy mentally and physically.

So to end this post, veganism doesnt mean a restricted or unhealthy diet. A person eating animal products can eat restricted and unhealthy and can have deficiencies. So don’t blame a plant based diet for those things, of course it does require some extra knowledge about nutrition to stay fully healthy while eating plant based but that doesnt mean it is unhealthy or restrictive.

Wanting to make a difference, wanting to save animals i.e not eat dead animals, wanting to help the planet…. how does that mean that a person is extreme or has an eating disorder? If someone says that, then they don’t know what an eating disorder is.

IMG_20170401_151150_258

IMG_20170418_122021_293

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Veganism is the same as an eating disorder? Veganism is just hiding an eating disorder?”

  1. Hi! I agree with you on many points, however, I do not see what good comes from making this point?

    Firstly, I noticed your response to a comment on your instagram, you said “not all vegans have an ed, you can’t generalize like that”. I think you have to generalize and speak about it in order to deal with the problem, because otherwise veganism will continue to hide ed’s in many cases.

    Nevertheless, I am a vegan too and I belive the only true future is global veganism, but we can not defend veganism from this type of critisism or force it on people who can’t afford it (I know you didn’t, just an example). Truth is, many people don’t have the funds, resources or time to eat a balanced vegan diet. We should be talking about plant based diets in rich people’s homes, not defend it from critisism that it is actually valid? Because if we defend veganism from these things, we’re overlooking the fact that nearly every teenage girl growing up today has an ed and that makes it very relevant to talk about how very young girls might not be suited for veganism, which you actually do, but I think making the point that “some vegans don’t have an ed” is very contradictive and actually upholds veganism as an excuse for people who continue restricting their diets.

    Like

    1. Hi Hanna,
      Can you clarify your comment? I’m finding your points a bit confusing to follow, but I sense you have a passionate opinion, which is good.
      In particular, I’m not sure what you mean by “we have to generalize”…. generalizations are just that: general and non-specific to individual experience. And individual experience varies wildly. I definitely do not think “most” teenagers have EDs, but I do think that people with EDs are overrepresented in the vegan community for the reasons Izzy stated in her post. Veganism can be a dangerous game for people who have twisted relationships with food (and this was my own experience as well). I appreciate that Izzy puts such focus on wait in until the time is right to become vegan, and that that time is not typically during recovery as the focus needs to be non-restrictive in nature.
      I’m also wondering what you meant by the “rich people’s homes……” comment and valid criticism. Which criticism are you speaking of, and how dos wealth fit into it? Plant based diets are actually cheaper as long as you aren’t buying processed products. Nothing is cheaper than beans and rice 🙂
      I think I’m mostly looking for clarification in where you stand on the issues that Izzy brought up. Healthy dialogue is important, and I dont want to miss your point and end up invalidating the whole conversation by accident.
      Thanks 🙂

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.